A statement from Air Marshal Kevin Short: I would like to acknowledge the work of the Inquiry team headed by Sir Terence Arnold and the Rt Hon Sir Geoffrey Palmer — and I welcome the Inquiry’s Report.
New Zealand’s armed forces are well respected internationally — whether providing humanitarian aid, reconstruction, training, peace keeping, or in combat. They are held in high regard for their skills, resourcefulness, their humanity and their courage.
Core to all we do are the values of the New Zealand Defence Force — courage, commitment, comradeship and integrity — values that are exemplified by the Special Air Service Regiment who are the most highly trained of all our personnel.
I want to comment first about Operations Burnham and Nova. I’ll then comment on Operation Yamaha.
As Chief of our Defence Force, I am pleased that the Inquiry’s Report has found that during Operations Burnham and Nova, our personnel operated with proper authorisation and conformed to the rules of engagement and international humanitarian law.
The operations were lawful, justified, and were planned meticulously.
Our forces operated professionally, and to the high standards we expect of our personnel.
However, this Inquiry Report demonstrates that we let our frontline service people down through a series of organisational and administrative failings that saw incorrect information provided to Ministers and the New Zealand public. And for that, I am deeply sorry.
Operation Burnham was a complex and dangerous operation, professionally planned and carried out, and involving a number of engagements with armed insurgents. One person was killed by New Zealand ground forces, and this action was in accordance with the rules of engagement and international humanitarian law.
The report concludes that, as well as insurgents, it is likely there were civilian casualties either killed or injured during the operation. Importantly, it also confirms New Zealand forces were not involved.
The loss of any life is significant, even more so if a civilian is involved in a conflict area.
Where NZDF did fall short, and where we are accountable, is in our briefings to Ministers and the public, and our administrative systems and processes, which fell well short of the standards we demand of our service men and women.
The errors resulted in a number of mistakes over several years and saw inaccurate information about the possibility of civilian casualties given to Ministers and New Zealanders. The mistakes were compounded when the inaccuracies were repeated.
The Inquiry makes it clear that there was no organised strategy within the NZDF to cover up our role in Operation Burnham or the possibility that there were civilian casualties however inaccurate statements were made.
NZDF acknowledges and regrets these mistakes. If we are to maintain the trust and confidence of the people we serve, we must be accountable. We must be better at the way we record, store and retrieve information, and then subsequently present that information to Ministers and the public. I will ensure this happens.
- Defence misled public over NZ Afghan raid
- NZ Defence Force to answer questions on Operation Burnham raid
- Crucial evidence suddenly upsets Operation Burnham inquiry
A number of changes to NZDF’s structure and systems recommended by the Inquiry are already underway. I am committed to do all I can to prevent this kind of mistake being repeated.
In regards to Operation Yamaha, I note the Inquiry finding that one of our soldiers has struck a prisoner after being arrested by Afghan police. The inquiry considers the way in which the prisoner was treated was inappropriate and did not reflect NZ values. Behaviour of this type is not what we expect, or demand, of our people.
The Inquiry has also made recommendations on evolving and complex areas of international law regarding detention during partnered operations. The NZDF will work closely with other agencies to ensure that our frontline commanders have absolute clarity around detention policies and procedures when working alongside international forces and partners.
The Inquiry acknowledged the thoughtful and careful work done in this area, and I believe it is important this work is maintained given the complexity of the legal issues being raised.
There is no question our administrative systems and processes need to be better — we need to own that and correct it. This includes reviewing how we investigate these types of incidents.
The Inquiry process was thorough and exhaustive, and we will carefully consider the findings to see if further changes are needed. I accept the recommendations for the Defence Force made by the Inquiry and will work with Ministers and other agencies to adopt them, including the establishment of an independent Inspector-General of Defence.
I would like to also acknowledge the soldiers from our SAS, and their families. For them, this report draws this matter to a close and they can now move on.
New Zealanders can be proud of the professionalism and integrity of our men and women serving around the world. They have earned our confidence and respect — and they deserve our support.
They exemplify our values of courage, commitment, comradeship and integrity.
And as the Chief of Defence Force, I would like to conclude by restating my commitment to NZDF continuing to uphold these values — we will continue to do better.
